Line Editing Or Proofreading: What Your Manuscript Needs Now

Introduction

You’ve just finished your manuscript – congratulations! But now you’re staring at your screen, wondering what comes next. Line Editing or Proofreading? Should you hire a line editor? Or is it time for a proofreader? Let’s cut through the confusion and help you make the right choice for your literary baby.

Understanding the Editing Process: From First Draft to Publication

Here’s the thing about editing – it’s like peeling an onion. Each layer serves a different purpose, and rushing to the final polish before addressing deeper issues is a rookie mistake I see too many authors make. Whether you’re writing fiction books or non-fiction manuscripts, understanding the editing process is crucial for publishing success. It is more than just fixing the typos.

The Different Types of Book Editing Services

Before diving into line editing and proofreading specifically, let’s quickly outline the main types of editing services available to authors:

• Developmental editing (big picture story and structure)
• Content editing (chapter-level organization and flow)
• Line editing (sentence-level polish and style)
• Copy editing (technical accuracy and consistency)
• Proofreading (final error check)

Free Resource: Download the Beta Reader Checklist

Line Editing: The Secret Sauce of Stunning Prose

Think of line editing as the difference between a home-cooked meal and a masterpiece from a five-star restaurant. Both might use the same ingredients, but the execution? That’s where the magic happens.

What Does a Line Editor Do?

A professional line editor doesn’t just read your work; they savor it, word by word. They’re looking for:

• The music in your sentences (yes, even prose should sing)
• The aesthetic of your prose (see how a sentence with too many punctuation marks grates on you)
• Those pesky repetitive phrases you didn’t even notice
• Opportunities to turn bland descriptions into vivid scenes
• Places where your voice suddenly sounds like someone else
• Moments where showing would pack more punch than telling
• Clarity and impact in each paragraph Smooth transitions between scenes and ideas Effective dialogue tags and action beats Proper pacing and tension management

The Impact of Quality Line Editing

I recently worked with an author who swore her manuscript was ready for publication. But after line editing, she messaged me saying, “I can’t believe how much stronger every scene feels now.” That’s the power of skilled line editing.

Professional Proofreading: Your Last Line of Defense

Now, proofreading? That’s your safety net. It’s the final check that catches those embarrassing typos that spell-check missed. (Fun fact: spell-check won’t catch it if you write “he was board” instead of “he was bored”!)

What Does a Professional Proofreader Check?

A thorough proofreader focuses on:

• Grammar gremlins that sneak into even the best manuscripts
• Consistency in formatting (Is it “email” or “e-mail” throughout?)
• Proper punctuation (Those semicolons aren’t just decorative!)
• Page numbers, headers, and other formatting elements
• Double-checking every single capital letter and period
• Consistent chapter headings and subheadings

Making the Right Choice: Your Manuscript’s Needs

Still not sure which service you need? Let’s break it down with some real talk.

You need line editing if:

• Beta readers say your story is great but the writing feels “meh”
• You catch yourself using the same words or phrases repeatedly
• Your dialogue sounds more like a business meeting than real people talking
• You’re getting feedback that scenes drag or lack impact
• You struggle to make emotional moments really land
• English is your second language
• This is your first book
• You plan to submit to traditional publishers
• You want to compete with bestselling authors in your genre

You’re ready for proofreading when:

• Your manuscript has already been through deeper editing phases
• The story structure is solid
• Your voice is consistent and strong
• You’re preparing to submit to agents
• You’re getting ready to self-publish your book
• You need that final polish to catch lingering errors
• You’ve already invested in other editing services
• Your beta readers are focusing on typos rather than content issues

Cost Considerations: Budgeting for Professional Editing Services

Understanding Line Editing Rates

Professional line editing services vary in cost depending on:

• Manuscript length (typically $0.02-$0.06 per word)
• Editor’s experience level and expertise
• Genre requirements (technical or specialized content costs more)
• Timeline needs (rush jobs command premium rates)
• Number of editing rounds included
• Complexity of the manuscript
• Whether developmental suggestions are included
• Amount of dialogue and scene work needed

Understanding Proofreading Rates

Professional proofreading services are generally priced based on:

• Manuscript length (typically $0.01-$0.03 per word)
• Technical complexity of the content
• Timeline requirements
• Number of proofreading passes
• Whether style sheet creation is included
• Additional quality control measures

Tips for Getting the Most Value from Line Editing Services

1. Complete at least one self-editing pass
2. Consider a sample line edit before committing
3. Look for editors with experience in your specific genre
4. Request and review their editing portfolio
5. Ask about included services (consultations, revisions, etc.)
6. Understand their approach to maintaining your voice
7. Discuss their policy on multiple rounds of revisions

Tips for Getting the Most Value from Proofreading Services

1. Never submit a first draft for proofreading
2. Ensure all major edits are complete before proofreading begins
3. Provide any style preferences upfront
4. Consider bundled services with editing
5. Understand their error-rate guarantees

Making the Final Decision: Choosing Your Editing Path

Remember: both line editing and proofreading are investments in your book’s success. Skipping either one is like building a house without a roof or foundation – you need both for different reasons.

Questions to Ask Potential Line Editors

1. What is their editing process and approach?
2. How do they handle voice preservation?
3. What is their experience with your specific genre?
4. What is their typical turnaround time for your word count?
5. Do they offer any guarantees or revision policies?
6. How do they handle disagreements about changes?
7. Will they provide ongoing support during revisions?
8. Can they share before and after samples of their work?

Questions to Ask Potential Proofreaders

1. What style guides do they use?
2. How do they track and document changes?
3. What is their process for maintaining consistency?
4. What formats can they work with?
5. How do they handle multiple rounds of changes?
6. What is their error-detection rate?
7. Do they provide a final quality assurance check?
8. How do they handle different style requirements?

Free Resource: 15 Minute Manuscript Assessment (For Editing/Proofreading) Checklist

Conclusion

The bottom line is to invest in your success. Whether you choose to start with line editing or move straight to proofreading, the key is making an informed decision based on your manuscript’s current state and your publishing goals. Don’t rush the process – quality editing takes time, but the results are worth the investment.

Take the Next Step with DCP Professional Editing Services

Ready to transform your manuscript but worried about the cost? I understand that investing in professional editing can feel daunting, especially for first-time authors. That’s why I’ve structured my editing services to be accessible while maintaining professional standards. My rates are transparent and competitive, starting at $0.015 per word for line editing and $0.006 per word for proofreading.

Whether you need intensive line editing to polish your prose or a final proofread to catch those last-minute errors, let’s discuss how we can work together to achieve your publishing goals. Use the contact section and send me an email today. Let’s connect.

DCP Line Editing Services

DCP Proofreading Services

FREE DOWNLOAD Here are the 10 Proven Strategies to Market Your Book Online Once You Publish

MY TOP POSTS

• Professional Beta-Reading Services That Will Elevate Your Manuscript Now
• Developmental Editor – 5 Signs Your Manuscript Needs Me Now
• Why An Author Needs Easy Digital Marketing Strategy Now
• Mindfulness Practices For Women That Will Decrease Anxiety Now

Stay connected outside my social media with my weekly Newsletter – Digital Content Pages

My introducer post – check out why I chose Showit as my website builder here

Use my code DCP to get one 1.5 months free on Showit

Get all the resources for your social media and digital marketing without breaking the bank from my DCP Shop here